Reality Steve

The Bachelorette 8 - Emily

Who is the Next “Bachelorette?”

The debate has been going on for months – who would be the next “Bachelorette?” Would it be a girl from Ben’s season? Would that pesky Emily Maynard rumor turn out to be true? Would they go completely off the board and not recycle someone? Well, the decision has been made. All season I’ve been watching Ben’s girls picking out who I thought would make the best “Bachelorette.” Only have two episodes to go off of, but I’m guessing that the public has a pretty good idea of who they like at this point. With Courtney out of the running, and knowing that the “Bachelorette” would probably come from somewhere within the top four, it wasn’t hard to see who was a candidate – Nicki, Kacie, Lindzi, and Emily.

If I had to rank them, I’d think that Lindzi or Kacie would make the best “Bachelorette.” Tough deciding on one over the other. Lindzi would be an obvious candidate because she gets dumped at the final rose ceremony and there will be plenty of people who will want to see her happy. I think the reaction after Kacie’s date last night was a positive one and she is somebody I think America could tolerate for a couple months. Southern girl, sweet as pie, and leaves a lasting enough impression on this show where people will be invested in her. As for Nicki, I just don’t see it because her divorce is too recent? Emily, well, I just put her in the third slot because I have a mini-crush on that gangsta rapping doctor. But I’m sure she could easily handle the lead role just as well as the others, even though she didn’t make the final four.

Having them go off the board and pick a completely new “Bachelorette” is just something I don’t see this show ever doing again. Hell, Mike Fleiss even admitted it himself in this interview he did with at the end of Brad’s season, where he so eloquently called me a “goof ball.” Thanks buddy. I appreciate it. Here was his answer: Will you ever go back to casting unknown bachelors or bachelorettes?

Mike Fleiss: I can’t imagine how we would ever get back to that. This works so well for us. People are invested in these characters, they are who they are tuning in for. We have enough new blood by design. We have one returning character with 25 or 30 new faces. I don’t think we need new blood across the board. Can you imagine if it was someone not like Ashley, who was brand new? It makes the show feel small of all sudden. It would be hard to get people interested.

So everyone who asks me, “Why don’t they use fresh meat? I’m sick of the recycled contestants”, there’s your answer. Never ask me again. I don’t see eye-to-eye with him on much, but this I do. He’s made a silly dating reality show last now 23 seasons. He’s obviously doing something right. No one would’ve ever though back in 2002 we’d still be talking about this show in 2012. No one. So, we at least have to give him credit for that. Outside of “Survivor”, no US reality “game” show (you know, where people are getting voted/kicked off and stuff) has lasted as long as this. “Real World” has produced more seasons, but it’s a completely different show content wise. “Survivor” and “The Bachelor” franchise are the gold standards when it comes to reality competition shows, whether you want to admit it or not.

Which is why the announcement of the next “Bachelorette,” while coming as a surprise to me, does not surprise me at all in terms of the franchise…

Page 1 of 3123


  1. mja

    January 11, 2012 at 6:28 AM

    I guess we’ll see how it goes. Can’t be worse than the current season of the Bachelor!

  2. quesara

    January 11, 2012 at 6:37 AM

    So not surprised! Though it seems a little unfair to Kacie or whoever they migh have picked had this not come about. They are just out of luck?
    I really liked Kacie on her date with Ben.
    Bentley would def be the icing on the cake!

  3. karynr

    January 11, 2012 at 6:37 AM

    I’m bummed. I found Emily to be very confused, insecure and cold. Hopefully she’ll warm up a little bit, but I don’t think so. She just doesn’t come across as a warm individual.

  4. freckledsmile99

    January 11, 2012 at 6:38 AM

    Love you, love your site, love your recaps! I agree with @quesara – Bentley would be the icing on the cake.
    Keep up the good work!

  5. Fassero

    January 11, 2012 at 7:08 AM

    Bentley’s add would be an awesome pile of awesomeness. Maybe they’ll have Brad make a return flight. Actually, I’m not as curious about why she agreed to do the show as much as how the “meet the parents” segment plays out if it comes to be. Their existence is about as much under lock and key as Bentley’s and we’ve long heard about how tight she is with the Hendrick family. Maybe she’ll get enough training to break that icy persona she conveys but something tells me right now that she’ll only pick the bachelor with the biggest……wallet. And I’m sure there will be a Charlotte Raceway segment and she’ll suddenly be cooler and confident about going there, conveniently.

  6. aemill46

    January 11, 2012 at 7:44 AM

    Think this is the best news i have heard coming from you. Mike F will have the best rated show in the history of all 3 shows. good move on his part. As for Emily im glad she doing it. who care about the haters their out there.. i think she has more fans then haters. if this is all true ?then i cant wait to watch it .

  7. cakelady

    January 11, 2012 at 8:35 AM

    I’m confused! I thought Emily didn’t want cameras following her and her daughter around. Also, one of the reasons she gave for it not working with Brad was she couldn’t deal with the way he was romancing the other girls at the same time as he was with her. She said herself she cried after every episode she watched. So now she will do it to some other guy. I’m curious to see how she will handle that. Seems like a double standard to me!

  8. joyce0303

    January 11, 2012 at 9:28 AM

    I am not an Emily fan. Appearing in The Bachelorette is not a good way to “protect” her daughter as she always claimed she wanted to do. Hypocritical. I am not surprised though.

  9. yorkshirelass

    January 11, 2012 at 9:44 AM

    Words as spoken by Emily back in July 2011

    One thing Maynard won’t be doing is signing on to the next Bachelorette. “Right now my main focus is being a mom,” she says of the gossip that she’ll star in the series. “I’m just like any girl dealing with a heartbreak. The last thing on my mind is to do this all over again…I’m done with all the media speculation. I want to move on and get back to normal.”

  10. Dianne

    January 11, 2012 at 9:57 AM

    You know, it makes me wonder if she knew all along that she was going to be the next Bachelorette, but was sworn to secrecy by ABC. I can’t imagine why she would agree to do this, other than for financial reasons. ABC probably offered her a huge amount, and as they say, money talks. Should prove to be very interesting. And I hope and pray Bentley is NOT a part of it..but again, if ABC offers him a huge chunk of money, we’ll be seeing him!

  11. jenniferboston1

    January 11, 2012 at 10:28 AM

    Steve: (and for anyone to believe he doesn’t read these comments, that’s silly, of course he does!), can you ever just admit defeat and that you were wrong? Stating that you never would’ve seen Emily as the Bachelorette, ever, ever, ever….now you say you just said that because that’s what Emily said? Give me a break. I don’t have any faith in your posts or predictions any longer.

    BTW, Bentley, bring him back for his dream girl, Emily.

  12. PaulaD

    January 11, 2012 at 11:37 AM

    Oh man, seriously?? I thought Miss Emily didn’t *like* the spotlight! Well there’s another season I won’t be watching….

  13. caitlyn

    January 11, 2012 at 11:48 AM

    Oh, boy. We go from the most boring bachelor ever, Ben, to the most boring contestant, Emily, as the lead. Ben has the lowest ratings ever on this show and he is absolutely horrible and ugly. At least Emily is beauttiful, and her clothes should be great. I feel JP and Ashley are the last real couple to come from this show since Ryan and Trista. So every 10 years they get a couple on the show for the right reasons who love each other and mean it, nothing fake and phony. So we will wait another 10 years, cause there is no way Emily will meet a guy on this show with deep enough pockets to compete with the Hendrick money she lives off of to meet her high priced needs. Good luck, to the poor sucker who falls for her. He needs to be very, vey rich, and maybe a guy whose wife died and and he has a small child, only way it can work for a guy to understand her priorities and pay her extravagant bills.
    And please, don’t wear the engagement ring from Saint Ricky on the show this time, Emily.

  14. caitlyn

    January 11, 2012 at 11:49 AM

    I’d love Bentley to come back and be rejected at F2, that would be hilarious payback to that dbag.

  15. fran89

    January 11, 2012 at 12:02 PM

    you are being really kind towards Emily, Steve! What´s with that?? 😉 And of course we want to hear YOUR opinion about why she finally did it – and everything else! I thought this was the purpose of this blog!! You seem to have lost your edge towards this one .. kind of interesting..

    I´m already dreading the amounts of: “… you know, blabla, you know, you know, you know …” we`re gonna hear from her. Those made me squirt in the last interview. Argh. I´m not a hater, she is a beautiful mom, but then again, not much more.

  16. lillithcsks

    January 11, 2012 at 12:30 PM

    I’m happy that Emily will get another chance at love. I hope they give BENTLEY another chance to win her heart. But I think the producers will tell Emily to get rid of BENTLEY. But if they have “the main man” BENTLEY … I will Definetly watch it!

  17. karynr

    January 11, 2012 at 12:50 PM

    I forgot about the “you knows.” Ugh! I usually don’t miss a season, because I love to watch trainwrecks, but she might be a little too boring for me. Plus, there is something about her I find very annoying. Also, I don’t remember her smiling much either. I’ll probably end up watching it, but there are so many other women who would light up the TV/show better!

  18. mommyof2

    January 11, 2012 at 1:04 PM

    I’m actually really excited that Emily is the next bachelorette! I always really liked her, and I love Charlotte, NC. I’ll actually be down there for my cousin’s wedding one weekend towards the end of March, so I’ll keep a look-out. I’m so glad they aren’t filming at that California mansion. I’m really tired of that place. I really like Kacie, but I think they were smart to choose Emily. I have to say that so far, Ben’s season is just boring for me, especially knowing that he boozes Courtney in the end. He seems like a nice guy, but he’s definitely boring and he doesn’t come off as very smart. I read his blog the other day, and it read like it was written by a 5th grader. The only thing keeping me interested in Ben’s season is the beautiful scenery of Sonoma, which is a refreshing change from the same old mansion.

  19. cmh123

    January 11, 2012 at 2:21 PM

    I really am excited to see Emily as the Bachelorette. I know that people are complaining because she is still close to the Hendricks and they may pay for her house but how about the fact that Emily’s Daughter is the only thing left that these people have left of there son why shouldn’t they help if that is what they would like to do that is there decision no one else’s.

  20. cmh123

    January 11, 2012 at 2:23 PM

    I say the show should bring Bentley back and have Emily see him come out of the limo and have her reject him as soon as he gets out of the limo. Now that would be funny.

  21. karynr

    January 11, 2012 at 3:06 PM

    Before or after she kicks him in the nuts on behalf of all females?

  22. cmh123

    January 11, 2012 at 3:31 PM

    After they way he is crying when he leaves. They should bring back Ashley to help with that one. Now that would also be funny.

  23. txazgirl

    January 11, 2012 at 5:55 PM

    Emily Maynard? Really Steve?!! I’m so OVER the whole Emily/Brad ordeal. I wonder what Rick Hendrick thinks of this? After all, it is his Grandaughter who is going to be thrown into the National Spotlight… Again! As for Emily, what gives? Certainly she doesn’t need the Money! I’m sure Mr. Henrick has funded her entire life after that terrible plane crash and the birth of Little Ricki. I don’t know Steve, she seems Fickle to me (the internet reports numerous relationships, flings, etc.). Maybe that’s why she’s doing it, so she can go from Guy to Guy to Guy, and gain some more fame along the way!

  24. hot4aztchr

    January 11, 2012 at 7:05 PM

    Emily=boring! Ugh! Would love to see Kacie B. as the next bachelorette.

  25. poddington

    January 11, 2012 at 7:09 PM

    while I admit I find southern belles very annoying (so no to Kacie), somehow I like Emily and will for sure be watching,much happier about this selection than any others. The only downside will be is she really can’t go for her heart (or loins as some have)b/c she will need to analyze what is best for her child, which could make for dull tv. What I find humorous is given the portrayed character of Courtney, I am sure she was hoping for this gig. Now she is stuck with a moppy haired dork who she never would have given the time of day to if not for this show. No offense to Ben, I actually like him, but please. This shallow wench probably goes for douchey players with money.

  26. hordac

    January 11, 2012 at 7:34 PM

    I KNEW IT!!!!!! That whole interview with Emily after the break up with Brad was Bachelorette positioning at its finest! I didn’t believe RS when he said she would never do it as it just seemed to be pointing way in the opposite direction. ABC was just going to unprecedented lengths to keep her in the spotlight so that the audience would not forget about her. The whole post break up interview showed Chris just dripping with sympathy. They were courting her, no doubt. They knew they had a complete winner if she agreed to do it so they were going to do everything they could to ensure it happened. Emily thinks that she is protecting her child somehow just because they get to stay in Charlotte? Barf, what a complete joke. This woman obviously craves the attention, despite what she says. I also feel sorry for the poor girl who gets to miss out on being Batchette from the current season! Hmm, makes me wonder like some were saying before if she wasn’t trying for this all along, and Brad had to screw it up by picking her as F1. I’m starting to think that Emily is one smart cookie. If this was her intention from the beginning she has played this all extremely well!

  27. morrigan0

    January 11, 2012 at 8:38 PM

    ? There’s a difference between inside information, opinions and reporting what someone else has said. Maybe it was a little naive to take Emily at her word AND maybe RS fell for the goody goody single mom act BUT she played it well when it reality “she doth protest too much” is probably closer to fact.

    I found Ben’s interview on Jimmy Kimmel intriguing/amusing this week, I’m not convinced he’s with anyone. I finally figured out who Courtney reminds me of….a younger Brooke Shields.

  28. funkydoll218

    January 11, 2012 at 8:40 PM

    Chris said in a new interview that an ex-girlfriend from Ben’s past is coming back to the show in the next episode. This girl is supposedly in the “Bachelor-Bachelorette” family of ex-contestants. Not sure if you addressed this in your blog yet, but WHO IS SHE?!!!!

  29. addicted2rs

    January 11, 2012 at 9:21 PM

    Why can’t anyone see that Emily doesn’t want to have a job. This show is going to pay her a lot of money and she might end up with a good looking guy that can take care of her at the end of this. She wins in every way. She also does like the spot light a lot more than she lets on. I feel sorry for her daughter.

  30. healersdaughter

    January 11, 2012 at 10:02 PM

    What’s funny is that I HATED her as Brad’s choice, because I thought that he and Chantel had what appeared to be a much more genuine connection (and I agree, on another note, with your assessment of Ben and his choice this season)–yet I *LOVE* Emily being the Bachelorette in a way I haven’t felt about any of the other ones since…ever?

    I think I just feel like she’s the whole package, and like knowing how much attention she’ll get. I dunno..maybe as a Southern “good girl” starting out anew after divorce, I myself am just rooting for someone I can relate to..I truly don’t know why, exactly, but I will be watching her show and believing in it more than I have in years–UNLESS she comes off as wooden in her interviews with the camera as she did on her dates with Brad. That’s all!

  31. JenJen

    January 11, 2012 at 10:10 PM

    @funkydoll218 The answer to your question is Shawntel Newton.

  32. floormonsterthom

    January 12, 2012 at 6:34 AM

    I thought Emily had a new boyfriend?! She was tweeting about him a couple months ago!

  33. Dianne

    January 12, 2012 at 9:23 AM

    You can still catch the video that ABC put out in error showing Shawntel as the “mystery” woman at

  34. JovisMom

    January 12, 2012 at 10:19 AM

    Bringing Bently back would be awesome for ratings!!! If he wasn’t such a jerk I could see her liking him… He’s a father and he is very good looking.
    Ben’s season is a snooze fest. I don’t find him attractive at all. I don’t find Courtney attractive at all either. I’m with Steve when he says that he likes Emily on his season.

  35. fantasysweet

    January 13, 2012 at 3:57 PM

    The thing about Emily is she isnt that healthy. You could tell by how she handled Brad that she is simply not all that self-actualized. I can’t imagine that things have gotten any better.

  36. fantasysweet

    January 13, 2012 at 3:58 PM

    Im sure there will be plenty of guys that want to date her though. I guess hottness trumps all the drama they will have to endure.

  37. fantasysweet

    January 13, 2012 at 4:02 PM

    Im not sure Mike Fleiss gets why the show is so amazing which is ironic considering he produces it. Its not that they choose a character we already know. Im concerned he is sabotaging his own show by sticking w/ this formula.

  38. pennyfarthing

    January 13, 2012 at 4:19 PM

    HA! I love the user name “fantasysweet”!! I’m concerned about the entire season being shot in Charlotte. I’ll miss the Bach Mansion! Will they wet a brand-new driveway out in Charlotte? No pad could be as amazing as The Pad!

  39. migrosado0179

    January 13, 2012 at 5:15 PM

    Hate that she’s the next bachelorette! Always thought she was a two face. She always said she wouldn’t do it. I feel sorry for who ever she chooses. She’s never willing to make any changes for anyone. These people even had to move to her hometown to film. She’s a spoiled brat.

  40. Ying

    January 13, 2012 at 8:34 PM

    Awww, man! Really wanted it to be Kacie!

  41. fantasysweet

    January 16, 2012 at 5:24 PM

    OK forget Emily we are obsessed w/ Courtney!! The lying cheater! We found this nugget on Cheaterville on Jan 12th BEFORE RadarOnline who promptly swiped it. But here it is. Look at the comments someone made at the bottom…sounds suspiciously like Courtney herself

  42. fantasysweet

    January 16, 2012 at 5:26 PM

    BTW people should boycott wetpaint and Radar Online. All they do is post teasers w/ zero content. They get you to click and then you see there actually is no real story. They have just copied a tweet or something ridiculous. They suck!

  43. monasez

    January 16, 2012 at 6:47 PM

    As I’m posting this, the Bachelor is on (just for background noise) and it’s so much funnier to watch now and listen to these “sincere” comments and knowing what is really going to happen. Example, when Ben and Emily say, if we can conquer this bridge we can handle anything….what tripe! Ben is so flat.
    Brittney left because the “schwing” between Ben and Courtney must be unbearably obvious. She did the smart thing by leaving. Doing the smart thing by staying is to get to the final four and having a chance at being the next Bachelorette (after Emily of course).
    The Emily season is the first one I don’t need to watch at all. Me thinks the woman doth protest too much!!
    @caitlyn – spot on! with the Hendrick money comment
    @Fran89 – thanks for the “you know” warning…I don’t think I’ll be able to listen to 5 minutes of this pretentious little airhead.
    I totally understand the revolving door for contestants and I like seeing nice, decent people looking for romance, that’s why I watch this show. But the tacky spread eagle snow bunnies, grope dates (not a misspelling) and “Springeresk” set ups for cat fights is spiraling this show down to the level of a “trashy Soap Opera” and one last thing…..Courtney…STOP TOUCHING YOUR HAIR!!

  44. seac

    January 16, 2012 at 10:13 PM

    I don’t get Ben’s attraction to Courtney. There are other women on the show who are much more attractive and have nicer personalities than she does. She reinforces to me that not all models are attractive, they just have the desired body type. This isn’t the first time that someone from a previous season has shown up, so the behavior of many of the women toward Shawntel was dumb and just reflected badly on them. Obviously, the producers allowed Shawntel to come on the show. I think it’s time this show went off the air. Reading the spoiler that Courtney is the last one standing, after watching her poor choice of words and behavior in the first episode, makes it easy to skip watching or only watch bits and pieces. I can’t root for any of them who behave like junior high girls and she is one of several who have done so. Silly show trying to create drama. No wonder I refer to shows like this as (lack of) reality shows. Ugh. Time to reclaim my Monday evenings from Mike Fleiss.

  45. star

    January 16, 2012 at 11:45 PM

    Mmm…interesting to know…!!! Thought ABC was prepping Shawntel Newton after watching tonights episode of the bachelor. Guess not! It will be very interesting to see how Emily will display her self as the Bachelorette. I will be definitely counting the “make out sessions” because she gave Brad such a hard time about opening up.

  46. canada girl

    January 18, 2012 at 7:44 AM

    Well I am not watching Ben’s season after reading he chose Courtney and now I will not be watching the Bachelorette, I do not like Emily.

  47. valerie151

    February 18, 2012 at 9:52 AM

    Oh no, not her again. What will it be this time – the child needs this, the child needs that, the child, the child, the child – what’s the child’s name again – Bobbie or Danny or something like that? Emily is your typical spoiled selfish Barbie brat who is used to always getting her own way, and will use any thing to get it. You idiot men (Chris and Brad) have always been seduced by the blonde haired damsel in distress type. In my opinion, the blonde hair is the only thing exciting about Emily. So she has this child and has to raise it all by her little own delicate lonesome self. Oh so big ef’in deal, who hasn’t. I don’t want to hear about it no more, nor the plane accident story again. Why couldn’t the next bachelorette have been somebody interesting like Michelle Money. Now that would be worth watching. When we met Emily the first time we found out she has nothing more to say after she finishes telling us about the plane crash and how she now has to protect the child all by herself. Gag me. But who cares anyways, I don’t, I’m starting belly dancing classes next Monday.

  48. holloma

    February 28, 2012 at 12:00 PM

    I can’t understand why she has so many haters. To me, she is very genuine. She does have the right to change her mind if she wants. Yes, she is insecure, but it sounds like most of the people leaving hateful comments are as well. I honestly think they are jealous of how beautiful and sweet she is and the fact that she gets so much attention from men. I’m so excited about Emily being the next bachelorette! Mostly because she is a Southern girl. Afterall, it can’t be any worse then the current season..

You must be logged in to post a comment Login

Leave a Reply

  © Copyright - All rights reserved

To Top

Privacy Preference Center

Close your account?

Your account will be closed and all data will be permanently deleted and cannot be recovered. Are you sure?