Bachelor Peter Spoilers

What You Will See Tonight on Episode #1

Photo Credit: ABC

Rose Ceremony #2: Los Angeles, CA (22 to 19)

Group Date: 9 women go to “Flight School.” Deandra Kanu, Shiann Lewis, Victoria Paul, Tammy Ly, Jasmine Nguyen, Kelley Flanagan, Victoria Fuller, Hannah Sluss, and Courtney Perry. Kelley got the group date rose. Here are pics from the date

First the women have to answer math questions regarding aviation from two women. One is the first blue angels pilot and I forgot to write down who the other one was. Then they have a midterm and are asked if they know the definition of flight terms like “flying dirty,” “cockpit,” “thrust,” “suck,” “squeeze,” “bang,” “blow,” and “windmilling.” This is nauseating already.

Speaking of nauseating, then they all have to get on a Gyroscope where they’re strapped in to this circular contraption and Peter spins them around. Victoria P. is dreading this because she suffers from motion sickness. A la Annaliese who had a fear of bumper cars and dogs, Victoria P. tells a story of how she once threw up on the teacups, so they show a blurred re-enactment of teacups spinning. Anyway, she gets on, makes it through, then runs to the bathroom and we hear her throw up. Peter knocks on the door to see if she’s ok.

Then they have an obstacle course outside to compete in, and the winner gets a private plane ride with Peter. The final 2 in the obstacle course are Tammy and Kelley, and when you get to the last stage, you’re supposed to ride this mini bike through cones and what not to Peter. First person to get to him wins. Tammy follows the rules and weaves her way in and out of cones whereas Kelley just rides straight to him and wins. Tammy says she cheated, which she did, but clearly production wanted her to which is why she was allowed to not follow the rules and nothing was said. Kelley gets the private plane ride from Peter.

At the cocktail party, Tammy tells Kelley she cheated, Kelley says she doesn’t really know what to say, then it’s pretty much dropped. A few others were upset but I think more women were bothered by Hannah Ann’s interruptions on night one than Kelley’s cheating judging by the reactions that were shown to us. We see Peter in his alone with Victoria P. and she says being a nurse she’s always taken care of people, but Peter was the first one to take care of her when she was sick after the Gyroscope. They made out. We see Shiann with him for a bit, but it’s only a set up for Kelley to come walking in and, yet again, Shiann is denied time. She complains after the fact saying she never should’ve let Kelley interrupt her considering she just spent all day with him. Kelley and Peter kiss. Kelley gets the group date rose.

1-on-1: Madison Prewett. Went with Peter to his parents 31 year wedding vow renewal. He surprised her once they got to his parents backyard and told her what they were doing. There were about 20-30 people there, including his friend Courtney who helps with his foundation. So for all the people who’ve already emailed me about Courtney and Madison leaving comments for each other on IG, just know they met at the wedding and that’s how they would even know each other. They have a dinner by themselves, Madison tells him she’s very cautious in relationships and takes things slow. Madison gets the rose. Tenille Arts plays a private concert for them, then we see everyone from the wedding vow renewal party surprise them and join in.

Group Date: This was at Avalon LA with 9 women: Sydney Hightower, Alexa Caves, Savannah Mullins, Kelsey Weier, Payton Moran, Alayah Benavidez, Natasha Parker, Mykenna Dorn, and Lauren Jones. Peter meets the women outside, said a friend of his planned the date but he doesn’t know what they planned. They go inside, it’s Hannah Brown on stage next to a windmill, and she tells the story of Peter and Hannah and their sex romp in the windmill. She then tells the women that they will have to share their own sex story in front of a live audience later that night. Sydney ends up getting the group date rose.

However, the last 10 minutes or so of the show ends is just Hannah and Peter’s conversation that they’ve teased since promos started. It’s a lot more intense and emotional than I think any of us expected. Yes, we know Hannah was never a contestant on Peter’s season and never shows up again because she was filming DWTS at the time, but, this conversation really brought out some unresolved feelings, not just for Peter, but for Hannah. Some highlights of this conversation:

-Once the 9 women split up to think of their story, they show Hannah on stage talking to a producer who asks her if she’s ok. She says no.

-Peter then walks in on Hannah by herself crying saying “Hey birthday girl. What’s wrong?” (Remember, this was filmed back on Sept 24th, which is Hannah’s bday). Hannah basically tells him, “I’m happy for you, but, this is a lot…”

-He asks her how it was for her seeing him on the first night limo entrances and she says “terrible.”

-She says, “I question what I should’ve done. I question a lot.”

-Peter brings up Hannah asking Tyler out on the ATFR.

Peter: “Did it ever cross your mind to ever ask me or not?”

Hannah’s answer leans towards yes. Believe she tells him she hadn’t heard from him, she knew he wanted to be the Bachelor, etc.

-Peter says he heard she’d moved 20 minutes from where he was living, he thought that he wasn’t confused, but now he doesn’t know. “WTF am I doing right now?”
This is all happening while both of them are sitting next to each other and Hannah has clumps of mascara under her eyes from crying so much.

-Peter then says, “What would you say if I asked you to come be a part of that house? Hannah replies, “Maybe…that’s a lot…” and gets up and walks to the other side of the room.

-Peter asks her, “Do you regret sending me home in Greece?” Hannah replies, “Yeah Peter, I question it all the time.”

-Peter says he never had any doubt that she was going to say his name at that rose ceremony. Even after she said Jed’s name, he was sure his name was next. Hannah replies, “There was no doubt it was going to be you and Jed.” Peter says, “You never told me that.” She replies, “Yes I did.” Peter, “No you didn’t.” But she never gives a reason as to why it she didn’t choose Peter over Tyler.

-Peter says he was watching the ATFR at his aunt’s house and watching everything go down with Jed and said he told his aunt, “If she wants to try this again, I’m 100% in. My heart sank when you asked Tyler out.”

-Hannah reiterates then that she didn’t reach out to Peter, Peter didn’t reach out to her, she didn’t think there’d be that much spark, etc.

-Peter says that when she showed up the first night, “I did kinda want you to come back on. I don’t know what to do about it now, I’m so confused.”

And that’s where the episode ends, so they’ll pick up from this point next week. Obviously we know they reach some sort of conclusion where Hannah doesn’t join the show, but the nature of the conversation and how intense and in their feelings both are is the reason Peter ends up cancelling the “sex story” part of the date, tells the women he wasn’t in the right head space after talking to Hannah, and he’d see them later tonight. But we don’t get that til next week since the episode ends with Peter and Hannah still talking.

Tomorrow I will have the rest of your rose ceremony #2 spoilers when I post your rose ceremony-by-rose ceremony spoilers for the season, even though a couple dates are still missing. However, I’ve already spoiled what happens the rest of this episode on my IG account (IG: realitysteve) and will be posting spoilers there all season after the episode ends every Monday night. I realize that people really do consume a lot of content on IG and I’ve finally gotten with the times. A friend of mine is creating all the images and doing it for me, and I think it’s kind of a cliff notes version to the spoilers that is easily accessible so you don’t have to keep coming to the site for it. I suggest following me on IG since stuff will be going up constantly.

Send all links and emails to: To follow me on Twitter, it’s: Instagram name is “RealitySteve,” or join my Reality Steve Facebook Fan Page. Talk to you tomorrow.

Page 2 of 212


  1. crushonspivey

    January 6, 2020 at 1:01 PM

    Most interesting thing there is Peter and his chat with his mom. And due to some of Steve’s sleuthing, I think it is safe to say who it is: Madison Prewett. Wasn’t she there when Peter’s parents renewed their vows? So there is already a close family connection there. nd I;d bet that is who he picks in the end.

  2. phlacampbe

    January 7, 2020 at 1:13 AM

    I’ll throw my guess into the ring as well. I bet he determines that he can’t decide between the two and wants more time with each one of them and will try to date them both for the duration until the ATFR. Then he will choose…
    Just a guess and this show feels like they need a new formula. It’s not like the show doesn’t already bring in 20+Million viewers as it is.

  3. jillmarie

    January 7, 2020 at 7:53 AM

    I just have a strong feeling it will be Madison. Wow they are all so emotional! I honestly would have loved Hannah to go be a part of the house! And I’m also guessing Peter does Dancing With The Stars at some point, because A)it makes sence, ABC and all – B) they showed him dancing in the intro and he actually can dance

You must be logged in to post a comment Login

Leave a Reply

  © Copyright - All rights reserved

To Top

Privacy Preference Center

Close your account?

Your account will be closed and all data will be permanently deleted and cannot be recovered. Are you sure?